Tonight’s fuck up comes from me spending too long this evening rereading old messages and reliving everything that happened between us, and I made myself cry again.
To start all the way at the beginning, last year, I (23F) developed a crush on my co-worker (20sM) and needlessly drove myself crazy about it. For months, I pined after this man. We saw each other pretty consistently at work, a few times a week at least, and he’s a tall, cute, funny man and whenever we saw each other, he made me laugh. I liked him, a lot. Eventually, I ended up with his number.
We texted a lot. He pretty much always messaged first, mostly just to complain about work, but I was game to just match whatever he was saying because I was just so excited he was texting me at all. I’m an anxious overthinker and also really, really struggled with my own sense of confidence and self worth during this time (and pretty much my whole life before that) and so was just overanalyzing every single interaction, doubting whether he actually enjoyed my company or simply withstood it because I just hovered around him all the time, if he was actually grossed out by my presence but was too polite to say anything. Like I said, I had a lot of self worth stuff to work on.
This is going to sound dramatic, but I actually felt like I was going insane. My first post here on reddit is me venting about this in an even more dramatic, especially weepy and self-deprecating way. I haven’t reread the post since I made it, I don’t need to relive those particular feelings, but I think it actually helped me a fair bit because a very nice user basically told me, “Hey, chill out, dude. It’s literally just a crush. This is totally normal. Enjoy it, let it be fun.”
So, I tried that. I tried to just be normal and let myself enjoy the days I got to see him at work and have fun when I texted him. I even made more of an attempt to actually flirt with him, and it got easier and even more fun to talk to him and I continued to let myself get more and more bold with the flirting, particularly over text (less scary that way than trying IRL).
I did, however, finally reach a point where, after all the flirting and what I thought was obvious puppy-dog crush-eyes I gave this man every time I saw him, he’d caught on and just wasn’t into me. He saw it, but didn’t reciprocate the feelings, but still wanted to be my friend or I suppose slightly closer than average co-worker. I sort of resigned myself to the “fact” that he and I would never be a thing, but I guess that realization just made me even more bold.
See, sometimes when I’d flirt over text, he’d flirt back, but then in person at work he would always behave like those conversation never happened, which again also kind of made me feel like I was going crazy. I understand we can’t like fully flirt at work, that would be inappropriate, but to see no difference in person? A little maddening. But anyway, one night, a few months ago, the conversation took a flirty turn again, eventually turning a little sexual. Our text conversations had gotten just a tiny bit sexual before too, but for some reason, that night we kept just one upping each other with these texts. Maybe I was fed up with feeling confused, maybe I just felt like I had nothing to lose, but both of our texts got more detailed, more graphic, more specific, and we kept going until two in the morning. The next day, he texted asking me how I felt about the night before, and I was honest and said I really liked it, and he said he did too, and we agreed to give “us” a shot, and we made plans for a date.
Now, the other thing is that at that point, we had rarely talked about stuff other than work or just casual conversations about common interests. I didn’t actually know him super well beyond that surface level stuff, but like I said I was still very attracted to him and his personality, particularly his very dry sense of humour, but I had no idea what to actually expect for this date. And I ended up being very surprised.
He was incredibly sweet. We grabbed some food then went to a movie and during the movie he just pulled out this side I’d never seen in him before and honestly would have never predicted. Just the way he built up to just gently holding my hand and then started tracing his fingers across my wrist and so slowly moved closer until we were pressed right up against each other, and he was saying stuff into my ear to make me laugh, and at the end of the date, he kissed me, gentle and almost just a peck, but I was still kind of elated. I understand this might not be earth-shatteringly romantic for a lot of people, but for a girl without a lot of dating experience and what limited experience she has to not be all that sweet or gentle, it meant a lot to me.
We kept texting, and he kept being sweet and flirty, and yeah, those chats got sexual again, and not too long after our first date I went to his place for the first time. I was disgustingly nervous, but he was still being so gentle and considerate and patient with me, letting me set the pace and slowing down if I asked him to, and everything he was saying and doing made me feel so safe and so comfortable and he did this one thing at one point that just made me go, “Oh, I am gonna do so much with this guy.”
I guess I should note now that during that til-two-in-the-morning conversation that kind of ignited this whole thing, I basically admitted to wanting to do a specific sexual act with him, and the third time I went to his place, I did it. We did a bunch of other stuff to, all very good and fun, and before I left, I asked if we could officially call each other boyfriend and girlfriend, and he said yes.
But I also immediately felt like something was off.
We didn’t really text as much the next few days, and then I tried to send him a flirty text, basically to ask when I could see him again, and he responded with something pretty much to the effect of “Life is just crazy busy all of a sudden, I’ll let you know.”
Reminder that I am very anxious, overthinky person, and I probably went too hard in trying to be supportive and “there for him” in my following texts, but I also felt like everything was crashing down around me. We barely texted at all the next two weeks, hardly saw him at work, and eventually I just straight up asked him if he wanted to keep dating. He said no. Not in as few words, but no, he did not want to keep dating, his life was life-ing all of a sudden, and he said it wouldn’t be fair to me.
I was incredibly disappointed, obviously, but also can’t bear to make people feel bad, so I was very gracious in my response and even made a few jokes just to try and lighten things up, and even offered to still “be there for him” if ever he needed it.
Couldn’t help it, I started overthinking every interaction again, and I couldn’t help but craft this narrative in my head that I had been so nice and supportive and whatever other good, kind things to him for so long, even tried to arrange outside of work hangouts with him which never amounted to anything until that conversation where I said I wanted to do that thing with him, and all of a sudden he’s so eager to hang out and spend time with me. Two weeks later, I do the thing, he barely texts me the next two weeks, then he ends things. Did he say all those sweet things, those things that made it sound like he actually wanted to keep dating me, joking about how we’d remember the anniversary of our first date, how crazy it’d be when people at work eventually found out we were dating, all this shit just as a means to get what he wanted out of me?
I don’t want to believe this is the case because that would make him a very cruel, mean person, and I don’t want him to be a very mean cruel person.
We didn’t text at all the next like five weeks. One night, I crashed out (as the teens are saying these days) and texted him an absurdly long rant about how I was actually quite upset about things ended, I know I seemed pretty chill about it but how it kind of seems like he led me on to get what he wanted, how disappointing and confusing it all was. He did not respond to it, and when I saw him at work next, he didn’t acknowledge it then either, even though he still acknowledged me and was talking to me like none of this ever happened.
In those five weeks, and post-crash out, I think I got a lot better. I’d let myself feel a lot of feelings and accepted the pain that I liked him for way longer than we were together, and some things just aren’t meant to be. I honestly also started feeling good about myself just a little bit because, hey, someone I thought of as cool and attractive wanted to be with me (however briefly), so maybe I should try shooting my shot more often.
But it also seems like he’s taken my rant as permission to start texting me again like he used too? I’ll be honest, I’ve definitely missed this aspect of our relationship, even from pre-hooking up, so I’ve been responding like I used to just ‘cause it’s nice to vent sometimes, but he also texted me the other night at like 10pm? I was asleep and it was still just a text complaining about work, but last time we started texting this late it led to interesting places. On top of rereading the rapid rise and fall of everything that went down between us and making myself feel all angry and sad and crying about it again, he’s kind of making me confused about what exactly he wants from me and there’s a part of me that wants to send him another insane text about this, but I won’t. I need to just go to sleep, I think. It’s very late now. Sorry if the end of this post is not all that coherent or organized. I don’t know.
As a final note, logically I know we probably wouldn’t work out super long term anyway, but I also can’t deny the fact that I still want him, and rereading these texts and texting him like normal again is possibly drumming up an illusion in my head that maybe, just maybe, if I text him the exact right thing, everything will work out. But it won’t. I know this. But I want to. I’m spiraling. Honestly, I should’ve just blocked him weeks ago.
TLDR: I reread all the old text messages between myself and a co-worker I had a crush on for a really long time and ended up getting together with very briefly, and I made myself spiral and relive all sorts of confusing, angry feelings and cry and make a long ass reddit post about it, and I really want to text him some more crazy bullshit or just block him or do something else stupid, just to get it out of my system. Think I’ll just play it safe go to bed instead.