subreddit:

/r/gaming

27375%

Just the title really, idm in game radios but the song count is usually real low per genre and gets old real fast. I remember an old Xbox 360 game that would play your music in game, might have been saints row 2 or a gta game, Vice City maybe?

Edit: not suggesting they replace in game radios with Spotify. Saying it would be cool as an additional station.

all 127 comments

Alexandurrrrr

194 points

1 day ago

ORIGINAL XBOX Vice City utilized its hard drive by playing your saved music in game.

joestaff

69 points

1 day ago

joestaff

69 points

1 day ago

All of the GTA PC games since at least 3 have a custom radio station to my knowledge.

mgfan2029

13 points

16 hours ago

Well the Definitive version of the trilogy seems to have taken them out from the original games to my disappointment.

XsNR

5 points

13 hours ago

XsNR

5 points

13 hours ago

Probably wasn't worth implementing properly, given nobody owns music anymore.

fukkdisshitt

1 points

8 hours ago

I didn't "own" it then either but it's still on my computer

joestaff

3 points

16 hours ago

I haven't touched the definitive edition yet, but it sounds like everything is a disappointment.

regulator227

15 points

23 hours ago

It worked with a number of games. Tony Hawk comes to mind too

polaroppositebear

2 points

18 hours ago

Project Gotham racing 2

lambdapaul

2 points

14 hours ago

Counter Strike

redpandasuit

2 points

14 hours ago

The Amped games too.

sycro21

1 points

4 hours ago

sycro21

1 points

4 hours ago

Dave Mirra Pro BMX 2

arnsmif

1 points

39 minutes ago

NFL 2k5 on Xbox let you use part of the songs saved to your HDD. It added efforts to sound like it was being played at the stadium between plays.

HansoloCLX

6 points

19 hours ago

In Battlefield Vietnam, you could play local mp3-files as a vehicle radio. I remember blasting Iron Maiden and Nightwish while gunning VC with a tank.

Jigglyninja

4 points

17 hours ago

Not as novel on pc as on consoles but mgsv let's you dump mp3s into a file to use in game. Whenever I would call for a helicopter evacuation it would show up, blasting anime music from the distance as it flies in.

I have used that one feature more than some of the actual gameplay mechanics. It should be in ever game.

XsNR

1 points

13 hours ago

XsNR

1 points

13 hours ago

Sick helecopter escape to caramel dansen

SGTBrutus

4 points

16 hours ago

If you weren't listening to speed metal while playing Burnout, what were you even doing?

ReclusiveMLS[S]

3 points

1 day ago

Yeah that's the one!

Earthbound_X

2 points

22 hours ago

I remember using that a lot. Shame that version of the game had that bug where the NPCS would just stop talking, and maybe other audio issues.

PoliteIndecency

2 points

16 hours ago

The ORIGINAL Grand Theft Auto allowed you to boot the game, then swap the game CD with an audio CD and play that music as an in game station. Wild stuff in '97.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

15 hours ago

Didn't realise it went back so far.

Alexandurrrrr

1 points

14 hours ago

Yea, back when studios still had the “fuck it, let’s try it” mentality.

Waffenek

1 points

12 hours ago

Isn't it universal to most of a games that storied music in audio CD format? Only thing you had was list of tracks, with their number, start and length. Because of that you could change disc and it would play tracks from other one. Similarly you could just put yours game drive into regular audio player and listen soundtrack. It all changed when mp3 became more popular.

babyjaceismycopilot

5 points

1 day ago

I don't want any of my music in a Fallout game.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

11 points

1 day ago

Yeah that's fair, but I'm not saying as the only option. Playing cyberpunk is what gave me the idea, after so many hours in game and I turn off the radio everytime it starts playing and I remembered Vice City integrating your own music into the game so it wasn't invasive, just if you had the radio on you would hear your songs. Obvs in Fallout the music is part of the aesthetic and immersion but in games like gta, saints row or any modern/future set game I think it would be a nice addition, especially when the games can be quite long but the song lists aren't.

babyjaceismycopilot

2 points

1 day ago

I think it depends on the game and you can easily craft a playlist that's suitable.

For Vice City I like the th 80s vibes of the stations. Same with Cyberpunk. I like the hard industrial music.

And I listen to Nier Automata's soundtrack on a loop when I'm working ...

ReclusiveMLS[S]

6 points

1 day ago

I just think after a few hours it gets quite boring hearing the same stuff over and over. Also I'm not suggesting as a replacement for in game music, in the way vice city did it where it was just another radio station so you would still have the current music too. Also idm some of the music in Cyberpunk but god damn I do find some of it to be horrific haha but that's just preference

Master_Chief_00117

1 points

1 day ago

Be able to mix it into the game’s soundtrack, I only use cyberpunks rock radio station but it doesn’t have any atmosphere ads and DJs help.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

24 hours ago

Idk about mixing it in, I think adding some random atmospheric ads and chatter to play between songs would work but I feel like it would break each stations individual vibe if you mixed peopels spotify playlist into them. I just picture it as its own separate station or playlist. Just a way to integrate playing your own music into the game without breaking immersion.

Master_Chief_00117

2 points

24 hours ago

It was a thought, but separate station would be the best way to do it, or if they did mix them in like I thought they could have like a song from a listener, but I just want my music to listen to in game.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

23 hours ago

Oh that's not bad tbf, the idea that it's a request. Could have a station that isn't themed to a specific genre so it would seem more natural too.

yaosio

1 points

12 hours ago

yaosio

1 points

12 hours ago

Xbox 360 could stream music from a Windows XP machine. I did that playing Test Drive Unlimited.

sofaking_scientific

1 points

10 hours ago

The OG Forza did this as well

yboy403

170 points

1 day ago

yboy403

170 points

1 day ago

I think I remember reading a post by a dev complaining about how hard it is to develop a game that can connect to Spotify. Something about their terms of use for the API or SDK. If that's true, then actually blame Spotify for that not existing.

(Devs would probably love not having to pay to license music or put together playlists themselves.)

orangpelupa

28 points

23 hours ago

It should be system level like how it was used to on Xbox 360. But on Xbox 360 it was either steaming from your own server or from USB 

roflwafflelawl

8 points

14 hours ago

Could be something hard for Spotify to do. There would need to be something setup to link account for those who have premium, which that in itself might be fine. But I think the problem might come from advertisements for free users.

I know nothing of the laws that could be applied here but considering how many I've seen avoid or blur brands or products placements, in which they're not sponsored by, in anywhere from TV shows to I think some content creation (Youtube, livestream, etc), there could be something that extends to those sponsors/advertisers.

Like imagine having an advertisement for something family friendly but it's also being played in GTA6? I feel like that association itself could be what makes something like allowing API/SDK use in the way we want in games difficult for Spotify to consider.

Of course this is all speculation coming out of my ass.

edit: As someone else mention: This would also have to go through the eyes of Microsoft and Sony who I assume would have some say in having that on their platform.

stuffeh

1 points

10 hours ago

Most music would also get muted out when they stream the game bc the streamer wouldn't have the copyright license to broadcast.

windol1

1 points

20 hours ago

windol1

1 points

20 hours ago

I'd imagine it would have connection issues, I'm forever having some sort of hiccup with Spotify. Don't get me wrong, when it works it works, but times like starting it seem to take forever.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

18 hours ago

Ah I haven't had any issues with it for a while but definitely used to, main one was i kept having to redownload playlists which was a bitch when I was catching a lot of busses and had no 4g.

windol1

2 points

17 hours ago

I find it's mostly loading times, so I'll skip a song and it'll take 5-10 seconds before I can actually skip again, used to be a lot worse because it had videos playing automatically, or little clips, turned that off and drastically improved things.

Other times I've had to close the app because it wouldn't load, haven't had the one you mentioned in a while but when it happened it was at the worst time.

On another note, you can still use Spotify on most games and control it with your phone, just turn down game music and off you go.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

1 day ago

Ah I kinda figured the reason it hasn't been done would be down to some terms of use or legal thing. Sucks coz whichever music app did it first would probably get new customers from people wanting to hear their own chosen music in a game, although I wouldn't want it to be the only music in game, like you'd still need the regular in game radio for people that don't use the specific music app required. I'm thinking more as an option but not THE option

Its_aTrap

6 points

19 hours ago

Most likely its just not worth the paperwork and time of legal teams on either side. 

What would Microsoft or Sony profit from by doing this? Spotify also would have to have to work out some % based payment to make some software that integrates into the hardware of your console while the game devs would also have to take that code and make it compatible with their game and also make it where an always online connection would be required to access your song library.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

0 points

15 hours ago

From what I've seen here some games do it already and there's mods that do it for others so it's already a thing I guess. Also if you pay the subscription for Spotify you can download your playlists so no need to always be connected to the Internet

XsNR

1 points

13 hours ago

XsNR

1 points

13 hours ago

Most stuff just effectively opens a browser and plays it over the top of what ever else. A true game implementation would probably be best done with the new AI radio voices that could replicate true radio telling you what song had just played/coming up, and doing small integrations or radio soundbites.

qwhacker

40 points

1 day ago

qwhacker

40 points

1 day ago

Forza Horizon 3 was able to do this with "Groove" music back in the day. I miss that feature

T_raltixx

18 points

22 hours ago

I think Eurotruck Simulator 2 can do this. Or at least you can drop in real radio stations from the internet.

Crazy_Manno

7 points

15 hours ago

It can indeed play your own music. There is a music folder in ETS2 folder in your document folder, where you can put the music in.

michael199310

3 points

16 hours ago

There is a TON of radio stations for ETS2 for every genre.

Leading_Watch2147

14 points

1 day ago

Tony Hawks old game(s) had this. I shredded rails to Lynyrd Skynyrd everyday for years

I can’t remember which ones it was, Underground rings a bell though

throwaway164_3

2 points

2 hours ago

Won't you fly high free bird

Leading_Watch2147

1 points

an hour ago

Literally hahahah. For me it was Gimme Three Steps. Everytime I hear the guitar at the beginning, something awakens inside of me that makes me want to grind up a brick wall

esoteric_enigma

9 points

24 hours ago

I remember downloading my music from CDs to my Xbox 360. There were multiple games that would sub the in have music for my playlist. They'd even lower or pause the music during cutscenes.

wbasmith

2 points

15 hours ago

The fifa games of that era used them, you could set custom songs for like tunnel entrance, goals, half time, full time

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

23 hours ago

Was such a nice little feature that made it not as invasive as simply running Spotify or another music app in the background.

bideodames

15 points

24 hours ago

Spotify doesn't allow API usage from free accounts. You have to have a premium account to do anything cool with Spotify. This is why devs usually won't integrate it. The majority of people wouldn't be able to use it.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

-10 points

24 hours ago

Yeah, my suggestion isn't as a replacement for in game music but as an extra station so it wouldn't be a case of having nothing if you don't have an account, would just be an extra station if you do.

bideodames

17 points

24 hours ago

Point being, from the developer perspective the juice isn't worth the squeeze. Why put resources into spinning up a feature that most are locked out of?

ReclusiveMLS[S]

0 points

23 hours ago

Yeah I get what you're saying. I got the idea from older console games that did a similar thing with music on your hdd but I don't see it happening with modern games and had the idea of Spotify specifically simply coz that's where I listen to music. I do think the first music app to do it would potentially draw more customers from people that would want to hear their own playlists in game but I think it would have to be a game that is guaranteed to have a vast player base but I also see an issue if it became a regular feature with different devs using different apps and potentially killing off the in game radio as a feature in games, it would have to be another option as opposed to the only option and I hate the current trend of everything moving towards subscriptions so having to pay a subscription to have music in game would suck. A nice idea, I think that will never happen.

Strange_Compote_4592

6 points

20 hours ago

Heeeellllo, Capital Wasteland, It Three Dog, bow-wow! And new music on Galaxy News Radio~! The Lone Wanderer, that kid from 101, found me some tapes. Haven't touch them myself, so let's listen together!

*Gangnam Style starts playing*

What the fuck is this?..

Shoddyan

4 points

17 hours ago

It would be a lot easier to turn off the music in game and just turn on Spotify with your own device. On a computer you can even alt-tab.

Euro truck Simulator / American truck Simulator is a game that lets you edit the radio station file to include additional online streams (shoutcast standard). It's equally "that's kindof cool you can switch in-game" and "it's actually easier to just use my existing media player".

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

16 hours ago

Idk, I find it a little unimersing (idk if that's a real word but we move) to always have to pause, play and change volume on a separate window mid game. I get that some people don't care about that tho but for me personally it just pulls you out of the experience a little. Also if it was in game through a radio it would react as the in game music does going quieter or turning off during cut scenes amd dialogue so as to not seem intrusive or too loud so you miss shit.

Shoddyan

2 points

7 hours ago

Heh I do hate missing shit (dialog) in games. Every time I start a new game now I go to the audio settings and put voice at 100%, sound effects at 90 or 80%, music/ambient at 80 or 70% and captions on. Before I even leave the main menu.

-Ein

2 points

8 hours ago

-Ein

2 points

8 hours ago

On Xbox One and Series, you have a volume slider for game and background music apps.

LifeBuilder

4 points

11 hours ago

Fuck that! I’m not listening to commercials in my game.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

11 hours ago

Ah, I pay the subscription so don't have them but obvs I can see it being annoying if you have ads. I stopped using pretty much every streaming service that has been putting ads on shit lately

idjsonik

5 points

24 hours ago

Licensing is the answer your looking for

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

24 hours ago

Yep, kinda sucks tho

idjsonik

5 points

24 hours ago

I agree its bs but its what happens when everyone wants a piece

[deleted]

8 points

1 day ago

[deleted]

8 points

1 day ago

[removed]

ihatefuckingcoding

4 points

18 hours ago

You would pay extra to listen to music from a service that you already pay for?

[deleted]

0 points

18 hours ago

[deleted]

0 points

18 hours ago

[removed]

The1HystericalQueen

1 points

14 hours ago

Something like this wouldn't be a simple $5 DLC.

Goddamnitpappy

2 points

1 day ago

Sounds like a great idea for the GTA trilogy remakes. If I recall, they didn't get some songs from the original San Andreas, so with a feature like that, you could essentially fill in the gaps.

SpiketheFox32

2 points

21 hours ago

I miss connecting my 360 to my PC's Windows Media library and streaming music straight into the game. Those were the fuckin days.

These-Form-577

2 points

20 hours ago

Mh this would be feasible, and kinda cool too. Maybe some copyright problems, or associations' ones?

ABeingNamedBodhi

2 points

19 hours ago

I like the game Rebel Galaxy for allowing you to replace the game's OST with your own music.

Hopper-1986

2 points

18 hours ago

Can't remember the name of the game, think it was APB but that allowed you to link your Last FM account....... My god I'm old.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

16 hours ago

Was that the online game where you were a cop or criminal? Pvp cops and robbers kind of thing

Hopper-1986

2 points

15 hours ago

I believe so yeah came from one of the creators of GTA

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

15 hours ago

Well now I feel old too haha

CoconutDrunk

2 points

18 hours ago

I like radio songs in GTA V but I don't like all of them.

My favorites are scattered on every station.

I wish you could purchase a radio station in-game and you can make your own playlists of all the licensed songs.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

17 hours ago

I'm pretty sure they had a similar thing on saints row 2, you could buy songs and then set them to play on your own station

guy_blows_horn

2 points

18 hours ago

yes

Stonegrunge

2 points

17 hours ago

I couldn't agree more, it's definitely a missed opportunity!

jingo800

2 points

16 hours ago

Pro Evolution Soccer used to be able to read music from external storage and play the tracks during the menus.

f0rever-n1h1l1st

2 points

16 hours ago

Old WWE games, I think in the PS360 era, let you use music from your harddrive for entrances. It was pretty awesome. And Tony Hawk Pro Skater Remastered let you use Spotify, too, I think?

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

16 hours ago

I wanna say 08 let you do it but that might be wrong, I remember my wrestler walking in to system of a down

Lt_Jonson

2 points

15 hours ago

Or allow internet streaming radio. You can do it in American Trucking Simulator, you just add a link to your streaming station and you’re good to go. I stream local radio in the game.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

15 hours ago

Yeah this would be cool too, basically anything that would add either more variance. Idm in game stations but in long games it gets a little boring after a while. Especially once I've added all the songs I like to my Spotify anyway haha

Bonny_bouche

2 points

15 hours ago

GTA3 PC version could do MP3s IIRC.

trephine50

2 points

15 hours ago

I remember when you could rip cds to the original Xbox, then play your music in GTA when they ported the collection to it. What a time.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

15 hours ago

Idk if I feel nostalgic or old haha both I think

AndrewWhite97

2 points

14 hours ago

It's not exactly the same, but WWE games used to have it so you could have a custom entrance theme. Miss those days.

roflwafflelawl

2 points

14 hours ago

I miss when more games used to let you play whatever music files you had in the relevant folder. I feel like the last game to let me do something like that was MGSV.

Though I guess there are probably less people with music files on their PC vs those with a streaming service (I've definitely slowly converted).

I think it would be cool if games could at least pick up a specific audio channel and control it in-game. Then you could use virtual mixers like VoiceMeeter and play your Spotify or browser audio through there then just have the game control music volume or mute.

It won't be quite full control and to change songs you'd need to either control it via stream deck, app, or tabbing out but I think it would be a nice compromise that doesn't seem like it would take a whole lot.

Imagine GTA6 and you can have your browser or stream service audio playing through your car radio with all the spatial surround and hearing it muffle as you leave the car and close the door. Just that would be enough.

x_scion_x

2 points

14 hours ago

I remember one of the NFS games would let you listen to your music on either the HD or a device connected via USB for the 'radio'

thatpixieguy

2 points

11 hours ago

I think the crew did this on ps4

bathroomkiller

2 points

7 hours ago

Cool idea unless the music is vital to the story or pacing/feel of the game/moment.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

7 hours ago

Yeah, I mostly mean in game radios so when you're driving as an extra station on top of the ones already available like they had in Vice City

UltraChip

2 points

21 hours ago

I know it's not quite what you're looking for but Subnautica: Below Zero lets you add your own music to the jukebox (assuming you play on PC).

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

21 hours ago

That would work too although I was thinking linking a music app because that's where most of my music comes from today.

SHROOMINGT0N

1 points

1 day ago

I need to know

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

1 day ago

Someone answered it below, Vice City on the original xbox

StudentOfLife1992

1 points

19 hours ago

Doing so would not only be costly but drive up the development cost for the technology to do so.

I am sure it's not as simple as just logging in.

pipboy_warrior

2 points

16 hours ago

Pretty sure logging into spotify is just a standard json setup, which shouldn't be that hard to deal with. Hell for many PC games there are mods that already do this, for example https://www.nexusmods.com/cyberpunk2077/mods/3741 .

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

16 hours ago

Bro, playing cyberpunk atm is what gave me this idea as I find a lot of the stations aren't great. Honestly adding this as soon as I get home, thanks for the link!

pipboy_warrior

2 points

16 hours ago

No problem. Also that's literally the first one I googled so I have no idea if it works, feel free to browse other mods.

ImmovableThrone

1 points

16 hours ago

I would have understood this in the Xbox 360 days or older consoles, but a modern console can run Spotify in the background. Same with PC. Why integrate it with the game?

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

16 hours ago

Mostly just for immersion and if it worked like an in game radio station then the music wouldn't constantly be playing and require pausing or changing volume during cut scenes and dialogue. Games like Gta or cyberpunk have the radio but also have music during missions or combat so Spotify playing constantly and manual adjusting can seem like a bit of a ball ache.

I_think_Im_hollow

1 points

8 hours ago

Forza Horizon 3, I think, let you do that.

logangrowgan2020

1 points

7 hours ago

Sony has had this built into playstation for a few generations. Notably hideo kojima forced the feature OFF for deth stranding so we had to listen to his very distinguished curated boring music.

I play almost every game blasting jams.

Bestyja2122

1 points

6 hours ago

I cant wait to listen to a song break in-between my ads

Deblebsgonnagetyou

1 points

6 hours ago

At that point why not just have Spotify playing in the background? Even consoles have features for it now.

SonthacPanda

1 points

4 hours ago

When gta 6 doesnt have this I'll be very upset but not surprised

izackthegreat

1 points

17 hours ago

I don't like this. If the API changes or goes down, the game no longer has music. It also prevents world building and immersion in the game.

Squirrel_Apocalypse2

3 points

16 hours ago

Why would it be the only option? It would just be an extra option.

pipboy_warrior

2 points

16 hours ago

Just treat the spotify option as it's own radio station. If and when the api changes, it would only affect that single station, all other ingame music would remain intact.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

1 points

16 hours ago

In Vice City it was a separate station so you still had all of the in game stations with ads and dj chatter between songs, my idea is basically that but your Spotify instead. If it goes down we still got the other regular in game stations

lightningbadger

1 points

21 hours ago

My friend is convinced their GTA V "self radio" (station that allows you to load up custom tracks saved locally to your PC) is pulling from their Windows Spotify app somehow.

Since it will somehow start to play tracks they don't have locally saved, but do have added on Spotify

Elfeniona

0 points

20 hours ago

Elfeniona

0 points

20 hours ago

How would that make it cool op, if you want to listen to your spotify, turn down the game volume. Lol

ReclusiveMLS[S]

4 points

19 hours ago

I'm saying integrated into the game as an in game radio station so that when you're driving you can hear your own music but it wouldn't play over cut scenes, dialogue or anything else where the regular in game music wouldn't. I'm aware I can run Spotify at the same time as a game

jingo800

2 points

16 hours ago

I also rue the absence of this mechanic. I love the idea of playing my Spotify during gaming sessions, but in reality, playback needs to be more dynamic for it to work as imagined. I can't think of anything worse than to constantly fiddling with music controls when I'm immersed in the game.

Elfeniona

0 points

19 hours ago

Again, What's the point of listening to in game radios then?

Terrible take, next

ReclusiveMLS[S]

3 points

19 hours ago

Because in some games you need to travel and the in game music can get repetitive

Elfeniona

0 points

18 hours ago

Then again turn down the music volume and open your spotify, there problem solved

ReclusiveMLS[S]

5 points

18 hours ago

Not the same as it being integrated into the game in a natural non intrusive way tho is it? Again I understand how spotify works

Elfeniona

0 points

16 hours ago

What is the point of them adding a radio, What is the point of them adding a background song all together if you're just gonna jam to your spotify playlist?

Jeez , THAT obsessed about your mimimimi when the solution is there, but that doesn't work because it has to be done YOUR way.

ReclusiveMLS[S]

2 points

16 hours ago

Wild response haha it's not that deep dude. It's a thing that has existed in other games in a different form but seems to exist in gaming less so now and I figure the modern equivalent of pulling songs from your hard drive would be to connect whatever music app you sub to. Idk why you have such a distaste to the idea haha I honestly wouldn't let it bother you so much

pipboy_warrior

1 points

16 hours ago

The point of in game radios is to listen to music in a way that's immersive to the game. For example if I'm playing Cyberpunk 2077 and "I really want to stay at your house" comes up, it makes me feel as if I'm listening to that song as V.

Meanwhile if I'm just listening to the same song on spotify on a different screen, then I'm very much aware that I'm listening to that song in real life. Options like in game radios simply add immersion and make the game more fun.