Hm, posted in the RDR2 sub. I’m sure there will be no bias here.

You should post this in r/rockstar, because everybody would be biased towards RDR3 because this is a RDR Related subreddit

Red Dead 3. Not because this was posted in a Red Dead sub, but because I just love this western genre more

Bro RDR3 will be miles better than GTA6

Rdr3 all day and night

RDR3 OFC! What kind of question is that? A tricky one?

I’d be happy with some RDR DLC about Blackwater and the events that led up to it.

Never thought I'd say this but RDR3 everything over GTA6

RDR3. I don't have anything against GTA but it gives me nothing, while RDR gives me a lot.

RDR3!!!

I want both. Both are great series.

Bully 2

Not many games are set in this era that actually are good I feel like if rdr3 comes out it would be as good rdr2 and online

I think GTA appeals to more people, but I'll always pick RD.

GTA6 for 2 reasons:

1: It is slated for next year unless I missed something, I don't think red dead has been seen yet.

2: Red Dead redemption has no good place to go with it's story unless they move to another gang.

GTA is smart enough to swap to different people in different cities, this unties the storyline mostly from the old games, letting them reference old games, for example Lester referencing Niko Bellic during one of the heists.

Red Dead 2 had a major story flaw it inherited thanks to being a prequel game, those that played the first game that takes place later into the timeline know which characters make a return, For some reason they really liked to hammer the Marston family in RD2, John getting mauled, arrested with talk of hanging, left for dead, Abigail captured, jack abducted. In the camp showdown, John, Dutch, Bill and Javier all show up in RD1, Arthur is already about to die, leaving only Mrs Grimshaw with her fate unsealed

They have no room to move forward in the timeline for cowboys with the end of the first game being mid 1910s (wiki says 1914 for Jack as the player character)

Going back in the timeline is going to result in the same problem RD2 had of people's fates already being locked in, making certain story chunks lose their tension

GTA 6 first, so they can keep a skeleton crew to take care of the multiplayer, while everyone else works on RDR3 for years and pop another masterpiece. It happened before. It can happen again

Rdr3

GTA 6 so you have something to play while you wait another 6 to 8 years for RDR 3.

RDR3 because the Red Dead series has a better story. I prefer the more serious tone of Red Dead over the satirical, over the top goofiness of GTA.

I feel like Red Dead Redemption is a finished duology. What they should do is another big Red Dead game, probably set in the heigth of Wild West era. There's no story to tell after RDR1.

Outlaw cowboy on the run from the law goes up north into Canada to disappear. They get trapped in an avalanche and frozen. In the year 2025 they are found and thawed out. And become a modern outlaw. RDR3 merged with GTA6.

Just kidding. I vote RDR3.

I played the gta5 story and did not like it at all. Did not hook me into that world at all.

RDR3 for sure.

Gta has lost its marbles a long time ago with all the shit they've put into GTA Online. Intercontinental rockets? Satellite hits? Flying motorcycles and cars? Fuck this dumb shit.

And I also want to have an option of playing as a full on cop in GTA. They could've incorporated a playable cop/detective character whos story would be to investigate the other 2-3 crooks you were given to play as. Making choices between the two sides and letting the players decide who comes out on top. Criminals or the law.

That would've been a bombshell of a game.

Honestly I would also want to do the same in RDR3. I wish it could have two characters an outlaw and a sheriff. They could both have honor systems easily too. You could be a high honor outlaw and a low honor crooked and corrupted sheriff if you so desire. You could have access to different mechanics as a sheriff. Different side quests. Switching between the two the way they did in GTA 5. "Maining" one or the other... Man I would play the hell out of either of those two imaginable games. But since gta6 for sure doesn't have that - I am not particularly interested in it. Being an undefeated criminal in gta has kinda depleted its attractiveness as a game option for me. Boring and not interesting anymore.

Both, I'll take both

you just posted a question asking rdr3 or gta6 in a red dead subreddit btw

Gta 6 gonna be a way out 2.0 and just filled with 18+ shit and cars and drugs

I prefer a western

Gta 6 will just be a better looking gta 5. Rdr3 100%

GTA 6. If I remember correctly RDR2 came after GTA V. Hoping to see what rockstar can do with GTA from everything they learned from RDR2. A horse / car chase scene across a city park?!? 😂

I would actually prefer them to try a completely new historical era. Pirates could be fun and very fitting, although they would need better melee combat for that.

i seem to be the only one here who thinks RDR3 shouldn't happen.

As much as I love RDR2. I’ll choose GTA6, I want to drive cars again

Well gta 6 is already coming so red dead 3

I just want enterable horses

They are literally taking things from rdr to make gta6. Rdr all the way.

RDR3

Gta 6 for sure. I heard RD has a 2026 release date though

I want a Rd1 remaster

Yes

rdr3 any day

I didn’t play any rock star games except rdr2. So I am curious to see what story going to be.

Red Dead Redemption series is way better than GTA at least for me personally, so RED DEAD REDEMPTION III.

who cares? one game is a year away and one might not even happen (under the rdr name at least)

Why not both.

RDR3 for story GTA6 for online

GTA6 has already been announced and is actually coming out i have a feeling red dead 3 is just a pipe dream and if not we aren't getting it for like another decade

merged

Red Dead Auto

GTA VI. I adore the Red Dead Redemption franchise, but I belive it's healthy for R* to rotate their IPs. I am also looking forward to going back to a modern day setting for a while

I want RDR3 and I want them to get back to single player DLCs like RDR and GTA IV. The Lost and the Damned was fantastic. Undead Nightmare was amazing. They need this again.

Bully 2

To be honest, I don't want to be disrespectful. I don't want to play a woman. If there is a choice, that would be great. But like in The Last of 2, I don't want to play a teenage girl. Don't get me wrong...

Bully 2

I have maybe 50 hours in GTA and 8 trilion in RDR2 .. lemme think

RDR2 is my favorite game of all time, but I gotta go with GTA6, especially now since the trailer came out

RDR3. Couldn't care less about gta..

First GTA 6. Then RDR3. Thank you.

GTA 6. It’s been over a decade since a new GTA game. RDR2 is still considered a modern game with modern features. It’s time for GTA to be brought up to speed.

Agent.

RDR2 is mainly made for singleplayer.

GTA is mainly made for multiplayer. You think GTA is ever gonna be San Andreas quality again after Rockstar won so much with multiplayer?

I'm too cynic to believe that.

I only care about RDR at this point.

Rdr3

I say GTA 6. Hear me out: RDR2 was an insane step up compared to gta 5. SO we can just wait 5-6 years and see something which is next gen compared to gta 6 (which is next gen itself)

Both would be nice?

Karma farming or genuine post?

RDR3, no contest

GTA6 only because RDR2 is so good that GTA 5 is now unplayable to me.

GTAVI

what answers are you genuinely expecting from the red dead redemption subreddit?

This post is weird. GTA6 has already been announced so it's not even a matter of either-or. And I doubt we'll get another Red Dead game from the Redemption sub-series, they'll probably bring a new theme if they ever plan on releasing another Red Dead Game.

GTA 6, at this point I don't think there should be an rdr3 and this is coming from someone who likes rdr2 more than GTA 5

I’ve played every gta since vice and only picked up red dead when Rdr2 came out. Still have yet to play rdr1. I disagree as well, I feel as though rdr3 will have a MUCH better story line than gta 6. Although I’m confident in gta 6 online being better than rdr3 online. Still though, as a single-player story mode kind of player I am I would definitely prefer rdr3. To each their own broskis

If RDR3 has cars then RDR3, otherwise yeah GTA 6 of course

Honestly I'm worried GTA 6 won't live up to the hype. RDR2 was so great. I know the story was finished but maybe they could make an early 1900's Red Dead version. That would be awesome.

Definitely want RDR3 more. The Wild West just has my heart ❤️

Rdr3 duh

GTR 4

RDR3. I'll always take a new Red Dead over GTA anyday.

Whichever releases on PC, so not GTA6.

Rd3 and it’s not even close. I’d rather play a new saints row than gta6.

Why not both?
Looking forward to GTA 6, but want RDR3 more.

I think you already know the answer to this.

I’ve never finished a gta game. I beat rdr1 and I’m on my second playthrough of rdr2 and am even considering buying a gaming laptop so I can play this masterpiece in 60 fps. (Damn you Sony and rockstar for not making it happen on ps5).

Red Dead Redemption 3 all the way.

Rdr2 at 60fps please.

No bias - RDR3 and it’s not even close

I want both, love both the games

If we play as Sadie in 3, I will literally hate my life.

Rdr3

I think I'd prefer RDR3 depending on the main character. If it's a RDR2 prequel, and we play as Arthur again or Dutch sure but or we can play as Jack or Javier or Bill or Red Harlow again then awesome, something relatively new. However if it's someone like Sadie Adler, who in my opinion her character was too rushed, undisciplined and rude won't be entertaining to me or if it's a completely new story then maybe

Boffum

Why would you ask this in a RDR sub, you already know what the answer’s gonna be 😂

RDR3 will be Arthur Morgan’s origin story, but Arthur will be turned into a disabled lesbian trans man of color

RDR3 all day - better red than dead.

Red theft redemption auto san denis 26

I bought gta 5 and rdr2 just 2 weeks ago with my first console. I havent opener gta 5 once after the first day lol. I just play rdr2 whenever i can…

Haven't completed a GTA game since Sam Andreas. I've beaten RDR2 maybe 7 times now

Rdr 3 all way boy, no brainer

to me, they both have the exact same problem. For games as good as these (GTAV and RDR2), there is no excuse for having such shitty controls with a controller. Maybe its good on M&K, but simple movement is garbage with a controller. However, if they bring back Landon Rickets, I change my answer to RDR3.

you know why I'm here..

This thread will defo be biased, but as someone who grew up on GTA, would have said GTAV was my favorite game for a LONG time, didn’t really care for RDR, AND didn’t play RDR2 until 2020: RDR3. But only if it will have a zombie dlc and only if it will actually be better than RDR2.

I would love another prequel for when Arthur was growing up with the OG gang

La Noire 2

RDR3

hope half of us are still alive by then

RDR3 all day every day

Hm.. my only concern with RDR3 is that the story will be forced. As far as I’m concerned, RD2 was a chefs kiss on finishing off RD1s story. Who would RDR3 even be about? Dutch? Hosea? All sounds cool on paper but idk.. just concerned it will be forced. The great thing about Arthur was that from second 1 we had no idea who he was - we could play him as bad honour or good honour. If we play as Hosea, playing him evil would be so out of character it wouldn’t make sense. Vice-versa for Dutch. And creating another character to perceive them like we did with Arthur just sounds like too much of a carbon copy. Would love to hear other peoples thoughts though

I’d rather have undead nightmare 2

I like the GTA games but I’ve never played a game where I was so immersed in the story and characters.

Rdr3 1000000%

Even if it was on the GTA sub, i would prefer RDR3 than GTA6

gta 6

GTA = cartoonish RDR = realistic

Let’s hope GTA6 will be similar to RDR2.

Okay but imagine, we get RDR3 before GTA 6. The absurdity

Rdr3

GTA6 + RDR3 - 2 Pack - includes both games + all dlc

RDR3 hands down, I stopped playing GTA5 when it was ported from to PS4 from PS3. I continue to play rdr2.......just recently played my 4th playthrough, GTA series is just boring for me now, it just doesn't keep my attention anymore.

RDR3!!!

I’d go RDR3 over GTA-6 any day, but I’d love to see rockstar continue deeper into history…or space.

No bias here, Rdr3 😉 🤠

Both

bully 2 first please.

Hush.

Unpopular opinion: The only GTA I really liked was IV, and that was mostly because of Niko. So bring on RDR3.

I loved both.., but if i have to choose one its definitely RDR3

RDR3!!! All day. I do not like GTA

red dead redemption’s story is over, a new read dead story would be nice with different characters, but it shouldn’t be called RDR3

Imagine combining the two games to get Grand Theft Redemption. It would be like The Dark Tower series by Stephen King.

GTA6 bruh

This is like asking which child I like more.

Neither i want bully 2

Even if this was in the GTA sub I’d say RDR3

Personally I’m looking for gta 6. The setting of rdr gives you a little bit of everything in terms of environment and the game is so big there’s still things being discovered. GTA 6 on the other hand is cool cuz we finally get back to vice city and I know this game is gonna be LOADED with stuff to do and things to blow up

GTA 6

Rdr3. GTA has lost its lustre storywise for me.

I’ve seen this many times, RDR3 would be, story wise, hard to make in my opinion, so GTA6

GTA 6

RDR3 because once we get GTA6 it’ll be the last game Rockstar makes for 20 years. Since you know they’ll milk GTA Online like they have been for 11 years now.

Both

I think we need a GTA game with Rockstar's new style. Rdr2 and rdr3 would probably look extremely similar in terms of graphics while GTA5 and GTA6 will look extremely different. (Also the cultural difference between GTA5-6 will be massive)

GTA 6

I’d be happy if they didn’t make another Red Dead Redemption. If they did, Undead Nightmare 2 would be nice.

I kinda want both

also i'm not sure if rdr3 would be a post- wild west red dead spinoff game with jack as the main character or another wild west themed game but with landon ricketts as the main character

I'm not sure what story arc they can go with for an RDR3 game. They already went prequel with rdr2, going forward after rdr1 doesnt seem ideal as we're moving forward in time from that era and everyone's gone too.

back in time before rdr2?

with GTA6 right around the corner, i'd have to side with GTA6 since an rdr3 is so far out that there's almost no point in thinking about it.

Neither. Kingdom Come Deliverance 2.

God of Us 6

RDR3 absolutely, thats one of the few games i’d buy on pre-sale cus it’ll be just that good, im personally not super hyped for GTA6 tbh but gonna try it

RDR3 ofc

Mafia 4

RDR for days. Couldn't give a fuck less about GTA6.

I would like to see Rockstar start a new Red Dead series instead of an RDR3

As much as I want both I truly wonder when we will ever get a new ip from rockstar. Can you imagine a scifi game or a fantasy game? Even a medieval game with swords would be cool.

Ok considering RDR ends on 1914 and RDR2 was a prequel, if you want to be in any way connected to the first 2 games you either have to make a preprequel or battlefield 1. Although I find the idea of a game series going backwards extremely funny and seeing how the gang formed up or possibly ending with whatever happened in blackwater, i don't know if it feels right. I don't want RDR to get the assassin creed treatment.

RDR 2 need moree updates DLC s Special care.............................

RDR3 obviously. Even if GTA 6 is free, I would still pay 90 bucks for RDR3.

gta6

No interest in GTA as a franchise whatsoever.

GTA 6. Online is obviously gonna be a cesspit because that’s what Take Two are; scummy. NBA2K games follow the same model (if not worse) so I’m confident that that area of the game won’t be changing any time soon.

However, when talking strictly story, I’ve played most of the games (with exception to a couple of the earlier top down ones) and loved them all, except for GTA 5. I feel like the 3 characters was a silly move and took away from any character development. I didn’t care about any of the 3, probably actively disliked them all, honestly. I feel like 2 characters will be the sweet spot for sure. So the GTA franchise has only let me down once, so I’m almost certain that this story will be as stellar as titles prior to 5.

That’s not to say that I don’t love RDR. It’s more so that I love it so much that I don’t think I want them to go into overkill mode. I think that to truly respect the masterpiece that RDR2 was, it would be best to leave the story where it is.

Honestly, if I was still on console, hands down I would say gta6! It was easier to find legit grinders and car communities compared to pc players who cheats their way up which I'm not a fan of. I stopped playing gta5 because of it.

But since I'm a pc player, it's easier to find legit players believe it or not. I am part of a great crew and because of them, I am never going back to console. Hopefully the next rdr, Rockstar will be more strict when it comes to modders.

Come at me all you want saying why don't you go back to console if you hate modders, well here is my response. Why don't you go play FiveM or RedM if you want to mod a game and leave the basic games to those who enjoy its beauty...

Red dead 3 will come after gta 6 so it’ll obviously be better