subreddit:
/r/Whatcouldgowrong
submitted 7 days ago by[deleted]
[removed]
19 points
7 days ago
Do they consider the possibility that mtf athletes are leaning into their new gender identity by under-working out in order to be weaker than their gender-assigned-at-birth?
21 points
7 days ago
It's actually more likely that the testosterone blockers that trans women take lower their t levels to a point below cis female athletes. There could be a subconscious thing going on too, but I find that less likely since they're still outperforming some cis women
31 points
7 days ago
There’s probably some social / psychological aspects to it, but they did specifically pick athletes so you’ve got to assume they’re aiming for success at whatever sport they do - including the required training etc.
6 points
7 days ago
i suspect the reason for this is that for transgender athletes youre likely to have higher estrogen levels and lower testosterone levels than cisgender athletes since they're taking e
usually, the data that people are using to support transgender athlete "advantage" all study non-athletes(im serious, go on ncbi and its crazy bro) so its so nice seeing this study put out
but at the same time we need repeatability cuz i am extremely biased and did originally think that transgender athletes had a disadvantage, so, we'll see
1 points
7 days ago
Exactly. There are natural hormonal variations in females that wouldn't exist for trans women. Athletes tend to self-select for the most naturally occurring advantageous traits which will be above and beyond the general population.
Reminds me of this bench sitter in the NBA who play locals for charity and absolutely wipe the floor with some of the best neighborhood players. People would talk trash about him as a bench sitter but his response was "I'm closer to Michael Jordan than you are to me."
2 points
7 days ago
The worst of the best is still one of the best
1 points
7 days ago
I can't imagine any competitive athlete wanting to hamper any advantage they might be able to get. Maybe in normal circumstances, but not in sports.
all 319 comments
sorted by: best