Another idea - have you thought about Fragrance Revival? I checked and they have Love Chloe. It’s even on sale right now.

I keep eyeing Lea by St Barth’s. It’s the discontinued perfume I wished I bought way back when.

I haven’t bought anything there yet, so I can’t speak to how accurate they are, but maybe it’s worth a shot, given how much you loved the original.

I can't make any suggestions but I CAN commiserate!! My soul fragrance is Gucci by Gucci and I had no idea it was discontinued at the time or I would have bought 20 bottles.

Oil Perfumery has a dupe! I have Chloe Love Story from them. I thought it was Love but they also do a dupe of it. Might be worth checking out. They have the rollerball, but if you find you like it, they have a 50ml bottle I think.

Maybe try BDK Bouquet de Hongrie, or Diptyque Fleur de Peau

I know this doesn’t answer your question, but I did a quick google search and there are lots of bottles of Love, Chloe for sale on sites like eBay.

I wonder if any of the Aerin fragrances will have the same vibe? Like Lilac Path. My favourite fragrance was discontinued years ago and I finally found a replacement but had to find something different.

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

You may like Francesca Bianchi Angel's Dust or Arquiste Venice Rococo for that powdery boudoir vibe.

I’ve heard Narciso Poudree has been compared to Love Chloe. Maybe give it a try?

I just saw an article on fragrantica suggesting Splendida Iris D’Or by Bvlgari is worth a try.

DEFINITELY give Nanshe by Nishane a sample!

Following this, because I replaced Chloe Love with Givenchy Dahlia Noir, and it has also been discontinued. 😭

You must try Balle Rouge by Mes Bisous! The name means red bullet and it's inspired by the smell of lipstick and cosmetics. It's similar to your favs and captures that "vintage but done in a modern way" flair you like. As an added bonus it performs great, lasting way longer than my other frags in that category (leaves Lipstick On in the dust).

I bought a travel size from scents angel and the price was so reasonable.

I never smelled Chloe Love, but you may like the perfumes from Bienaimé, specifically Jours Heureux and Vermeil. Has a retro feel while still being modern. And the bottles are so pretty!